i went to see cloverfield last night..
this will serve as my review..
i promise this will be the best review of cloverfield you will ever read..
i make that promise because this morning i heard someone described as a “promising young writer” and i thought that sounded like a good thing to be..
since we’ve established the fact that i am indeed a writer, and i just promised something, i guess that makes me a promising writer..
two out of three ain’t bad..
now, onto the review..
like all of my reviews, this one will assume way too much about your knowledge of the film, spoil it for anyone who hasn’t seen it, not include any kind of useful information at all, and be completely on the money..
first of all, at our theatre they made people read a sign that said “cloverfield can cause epileptic seizures, etc” before they’d sell you a ticket.. that’s always a good sign for a movie..
hint - SIT IN THE BACK
secondly, i should say i agree with this person who has a problem with the opening..
he’s right - if you are the person in the future watching this camera footage, and you tell us the camera came from “the area formally known as central park”, then you’re implying there is some new name for that area..
if so, why wouldn’t you just use that name unless you’re trying to speak to the audience of a movie theatre in your distant past who would only know it as “central park”?
if you instead said “this camera was found in ‘monsterguts park’ under a bridge”, and then showed us a shot of central park, guess what would happen?
we would know you meant central park.. and we would know you’re from the distant future..
and here lies the real problem with this movie..
the movie is not set in present day..
it’s set in the future..
we know this not only because of the “park previously known as ‘central’” tag, but also because we’re watching footage which was previously taped..
so by definition, we the audience, are positioned post event in the timeline..
and, i must say, as a member of that audience.. if these events have happened - if a seven hundred foot monster has indeed attacked manhattan..
if the army, navy, air force, and marines have successfully counterattacked..
and if these events were well documented by thousands of cameras all over the city including every major news organization..
then why.. please tell me why..
are we watching this shaky, crappy, poorly thought out reel of one guy trying to find his girlfriend?
SHOW ME THE MONSTER!
give me the cnn feed, fox, msnbc..
the network shots.. ALL OF IT..
i want to know what happened!
i don’t care about rob and beth AT ALL..
i might.. later.. after i’ve had my fill of monster..
maybe then i could take some time for a little personal interest story surrounding the catastrophic event..
but let’s not use that as the one single historical reference point..
pretty slick monster though.. i will give them that..
big..
and nasty..
which is exactly how i like my monsters..
the little drop-off midget monsters were underachievers i thought.. not sure what that was about..
i’m guessing there’s a lot of those creatures littering the cutting room floor..
anyway, not the worst movie you’ll ever see, but definitely not the best..
i promise..